Meeting - demo_wtfisthis
Unknown
- Okay, have we still got Rory or Rory is gone?
Unknown
- I don't see him either.
Unknown
- Anyway, this is kind of a side tangent.
Unknown
So not so important, but basically he introduced me
Unknown
to the concept of membrane computing.
Unknown
And that's how cells in, you know, the body,
Unknown
for example, you have inside a cell,
Unknown
you have an organelle.
Unknown
So organelles are holonically nested in cells,
Unknown
which are then nested in organs,
Unknown
which are then nested in the organism,
Unknown
which are then nested in the superorganized organism.
Unknown
And if you go inside the body,
Unknown
like cells do computation with each other
Unknown
by usually protein, sorry, not protein,
Unknown
proton transfer across membranes.
Unknown
So the membrane itself is some sort of a gate
Unknown
and based on the chemical reactions happening in cells
Unknown
and between each other,
Unknown
protons often transfer across the membrane
Unknown
and that's your computation.
Unknown
But this is where like we need,
Unknown
everybody will eventually get on this,
Unknown
but if we're really used to thinking in client service space
Unknown
or we're just like solving, we're solving hard stuff, right?
Unknown
And we have one brain.
Unknown
So we tend to think in a non-agent centric
Unknown
or non-membrane computing way,
Unknown
but basically like computation in the body
Unknown
is happening in an incredibly multi-parallelized way
Unknown
where every cell is doing local computation
Unknown
through its messaging to other cells
Unknown
and then you have an emergent net effect of that computation
Unknown
and how the body is able to function, right?
Unknown
In the same way, so we're all used to an architecture,
Unknown
a client server architecture,
Unknown
where even if we're being like,
Unknown
oh, you should all run all your own peers,
Unknown
it's not membrane computing.
Unknown
We're each running all our own peers
Unknown
and they're all living in a slightly different
Unknown
centralized computation space
Unknown
and there's no substrate between the peers
Unknown
that allows the computation to happen
Unknown
in the interactions between the peers themselves.
Unknown
So this is the key, like we're gonna offload computation
Unknown
from something like group dynamics
Unknown
needing to be simulated on a server
Unknown
and then like transfer as like incentives to the agents
Unknown
to kind of, if we can predict how agents
Unknown
in the network would react according
Unknown
to certain algorithms and stuff,
Unknown
well then let's bake the algorithms into the substrate
Unknown
so that purely by their interaction with each other
Unknown
that we don't need to simulate
Unknown
or keep an account of on a central server somewhere,
Unknown
they're going to do the computation just by living,
Unknown
just by interacting with each other,
Unknown
just by doing transactions like proton transfer
Unknown
across their membranes.
Unknown
And this is where Theos comes in
Unknown
and this is why I think we're able to grok
Unknown
these really high order complexity structures.
Unknown
Like Roberto and I spent two years figuring this out
Unknown
and how to implement a macroeconomic system
Unknown
that is coherent and has coherent design outcomes
Unknown
onto the pricing system that could then get implemented
Unknown
on something like Holochain.
Unknown
But I don't think it could have been implemented
Unknown
on Holochain, I think we needed what we're talking about now.
Unknown
And basically that's translating.
Unknown
So Roberto worked in AI and I guess he had an insight
Unknown
which was that profit is the objective function
Unknown
in a multi-agent simulation
Unknown
and that that is the driving logic of the market-based system.
Unknown
So you're driving behavior based on how profit is constructed.
Unknown
And so by decomposing profit
Unknown
and reconstructing how prices are made,
Unknown
then you can reprogram the group behavior of the system
Unknown
in one place just by updating the pricing paradigm.
Unknown
And so how are we gonna implement that?
Unknown
Oh, okay, let's spend two years on figuring out the subsystems
Unknown
and the stuff we're talking about today
Unknown
is one of those subsystems.
Unknown
So you need a substrate through which the people interact.
Unknown
And this is like the anthropological leap,
Unknown
like we're all individual beings interacting
Unknown
and we are doing like remembering computing
Unknown
whether we know it or not through just interacting
Unknown
in the economy and such.
Unknown
But there's no substrate to pass really important
Unknown
other information that allows us to do it
Unknown
in a way that doesn't rely on shitty systems
Unknown
like competition and price convergence
Unknown
and all this kind of stuff.
Unknown
So by providing this substrate
Unknown
that the membrane computing information can flow over,
Unknown
then a whole lot of amazing convergence
Unknown
becomes possible.
Unknown
So this is like the addressing schema
Unknown
is that substrate, right?
Unknown
Now we have a holographic character space essentially
Unknown
that can route anything and allow us to do membrane computing
Unknown
and end dimensions on data, on access rights on people,
Unknown
on whatever, whatever, whatever,
Unknown
without needing to simulate everything
Unknown
or without needing a blockchain,
Unknown
which is this one tiny bottleneck
Unknown
through which everyone is trying to see shared truth.
Unknown
You know, we don't need that.
Unknown
And we can act locally between peers
Unknown
on whatever's relevant to us,
Unknown
but that can all flow up into higher order spaces
Unknown
and we can harmonize the world behavior
Unknown
through a shared substrate.
Unknown
And I guess like for me, this is another opportunity
Unknown
to try to get Jeff to build what I wanted.
Unknown
Like, so we were talking about like,
Unknown
oh, how do we access this?
Unknown
How do we access this website
Unknown
on reticulum or in a data aware way, right?
Unknown
So now when somebody connects,
Unknown
they can have like a little beeping light that's like,
Unknown
did I go on reticulum or did I go on the internet?
Unknown
And it's actually the data packet itself
Unknown
that can tell them that.
Unknown
- That feels pretty cool.
Unknown
- Yeah, so the thing is like, okay,
Unknown
well then if we've got this Hellonic space,
Unknown
then how do we figure out the domain name
Unknown
that this person's allowed to have on this website?
Unknown
And like, you know, you've got DNS,
Unknown
which is like, we've got one global namespace.
Unknown
How do we decide who gets to have Google.com, you know?
Unknown
And like, you know, there's the ICANN registrar
Unknown
and all this stuff.
Unknown
And like, you gotta go in auctions for millions of dollars
Unknown
to get that name.
Unknown
So there have been other projects like handshake name service
Unknown
that is like, well, like having a centralized registrar
Unknown
that is controlled by some governing body.
Unknown
That's kind of shitty.
Unknown
Like, let's allow a decentralized registrar
Unknown
and have Vicray auctions through which people
Unknown
can claim the name.
Unknown
And a different schema basically
Unknown
for how names get returned to the pool
Unknown
and how names get won in auctions and stuff.
Unknown
But so pay attention, Jeff.
Unknown
Like basically, yeah, the question is, right.
Unknown
So the thing is, so I started thinking like,
Unknown
well, we had a conversation that was like,
Unknown
there's artificial scarcity here, obviously, right?
Unknown
Like, why is there only one Google.com?
Unknown
If you're sort of familiar with Holonix stuff
Unknown
and Holonix topology and membrane computing and like,
Unknown
like actually what people are competing over
Unknown
is not Google.com.
Unknown
They're competing over the right
Unknown
that they get to assert that everyone else
Unknown
should call their site Google.com.
Unknown
So like, I'm claiming that you all need to call
Unknown
the word pointing to my name, my site, Google.com.
Unknown
And actually, if you follow on from like,
Unknown
HoloChains, Rationale and all this stuff,
Unknown
well, like actually, so I figured out
Unknown
a better example for this, Jeff.
Unknown
Like, what's the name of a person that,
Unknown
just give me a name of a friend that, you know,
Unknown
that's not here.
Unknown
- Rory.
Unknown
- Okay, Rory.
Unknown
Like, how do I know that the word Rory just said
Unknown
is pointing to probably an Irish guy
Unknown
with a beard and some fuzzy orange hair?
Unknown
Like, and not my other friend Rory
Unknown
or the other guy on the other side of the world that's Rory.
Unknown
Oh, shit.
Unknown
We don't have a global namespace for human names.
Unknown
Like, that would be stupid.
Unknown
We just need to know that when somebody says Rory in context,
Unknown
it's referring to, it's pointing to this Rory.
Unknown
So like, we could have a DOM system where
Unknown
only one person is allowed to be,
Unknown
to get everyone to call themselves Rory
Unknown
and then force everyone to go in really expensive auctions
Unknown
to try to be called Rory,
Unknown
or we could be like, no, like the context matters, right?
Unknown
So, on any frack-holonic level of context,
Unknown
you can have a namespace,
Unknown
which actually happens on the internet, right?
Unknown
Like, inside your local router,
Unknown
you can run a domain name server
Unknown
so that all your local hosts have
Unknown
whatever name you want to call them.
Unknown
But for the internet in general, they didn't apply that
Unknown
and made this fake scarcity place
Unknown
where there has to be a global namespace.
Unknown
We don't have to do that.
Unknown
So instead of using Handshake,
Unknown
which had some really cool stuff in it, by the way, anyway,
Unknown
Jeff, basically, we want to have
Unknown
Holonic nameservers that use a different kind of logic
Unknown
than auctions and scarcity to provision who gets what name.
Unknown
Basically, anyone at the lowest Holonic level
Unknown
can come out and say, I'm Godfree.
Unknown
You guys can call me Godfree.
Unknown
But if somebody has like another friend Godfree,
Unknown
they're like, oh, shit, like,
Unknown
how am I going to know when someone says Godfree,
Unknown
like what it's pointing to?
Unknown
Well, guess what?
Unknown
That person's got their own local namespace
Unknown
that's like, I'm Godfree.
Unknown
And then the person in between who knows two Godfree's
Unknown
has to have some algorithm for being like,
Unknown
ah, well, you know, which one do I call Godfree?
Unknown
Like we need to do a mediation here.
Unknown
Like you can be Godfree one, you can be Godfree two or whatever.
Unknown
But the point is that doesn't have to affect everyone else.
Unknown
Like Jeff, who only knows one Godfree.
Unknown
And then so at the higher level of Holonic scale,
Unknown
he's got our namespace.
Unknown
And it knows that Godfree points to your address, right?
Unknown
And so on and so forth until you get all the way up the chain.
Unknown
And basically you can have n levels of people over,
Unknown
like, what do you call it?
Unknown
When you like overly use the same thing in computation.
Unknown
Anyway, you're using Godfree multiple times
Unknown
to refer to multiple pointing to multiple different places,
Unknown
but it doesn't really matter
Unknown
because each of those is in context.
Unknown
And so this is where I did a rant on Signal,
Unknown
but I could see that you didn't receive all the messages, Jeff,
Unknown
about going into complex numbers and stuff.
Unknown
But like basically,
Unknown
this, you would love it, Jeff.
Unknown
Like in a Mycelia.
Unknown
So you don't need any options.
Unknown
Yeah, you don't need any options whatsoever
Unknown
to provision the namespace,
Unknown
but to also return names to the pool.
Unknown
So like if God forbid, touch wood,
Unknown
I hope this is real wood, Godfree dies.
Unknown
Is no one allowed to be called Godfree anymore?
Unknown
I mean, maybe in some cultures,
Unknown
but like in general, we're used to a system
Unknown
in which Godfree returns to the namespace
Unknown
and new Godfree is allowed to arise.
Unknown
And we just move the pointer, you know,
Unknown
of Godfree locally to this new child, right?
Unknown
And this is like trees, you know, you're dropping leaf nodes
Unknown
or like you're having a regeneration
Unknown
to return Godfree to the namespace.
Unknown
And this is where like, I do wanna sit with you, Jeff,
Unknown
and really go through the philosophy of this,
Unknown
because yet you don't need options.
Unknown
Part of the problem of money is that it has positive numbers
Unknown
and it doesn't have an affordance
Unknown
to model regeneration as an incentive.
Unknown
And that's why like in Theos,
Unknown
we had balances between minus one and plus one,
Unknown
and then a schema for how death and loss and regeneration,
Unknown
link to consumption and demand side.
Unknown
But anyway, like basically,
Unknown
we can use like neural networks, like mercilial networks,
Unknown
like how do you choose that this name in this local space
Unknown
should refer to this address?
Unknown
Well, the more it is used,
Unknown
the more somebody says Godfree referring to that person,
Unknown
the more waiting factor you apply to Godfree
Unknown
in your local namespace pointing to the sire
Unknown
that we have in this room.
Unknown
And-- - Oh, that makes sense.
Unknown
- Yeah, and the less they're using all the more
Unknown
they're pointing to other Godfree,
Unknown
well, the more waiting factor you apply over there.
Unknown
And so this is similar to what we did with the K&N thing
Unknown
with the replacement for Shamir's secret sharing.
Unknown
It's like the namespace is self provisioning by use,
Unknown
just like normal names.
Unknown
The more that I say Jeff referring to you,
Unknown
the more it makes sense that I'm referring to you.
Unknown
And the less, then the less.
Unknown
And then eventually, if no one is saying Jeff anymore,
Unknown
there's no computer out there
Unknown
that's like remove Jeff.com from the namespace.
Unknown
It's just like the waiting factor has gone to zero.
Unknown
And then if some new Jeff is born, that can become his thing.
Unknown
So, and if you do this on N levels of Hellonic-ness,
Unknown
you don't have to do auctions.
Unknown
You don't have to do artificial scarcity on the namespace.
Unknown
You just do it like people actually use human names
Unknown
and anyone that has contextual relevance
Unknown
is any website that you're trying to serve
Unknown
has contextual relevance.
Unknown
And people will find that website
Unknown
because it was shared to them
Unknown
by somebody in their context, obviously.
Unknown
And like, you know, and it's similar to memes.
Unknown
It's like, you don't have to have an auction
Unknown
over like the funniest meme or something like memes rise,
Unknown
they decay, you know, they kind of go,
Unknown
some people hear about them, some people don't.
Unknown
Maybe the whole internet hears about them
Unknown
and then it's in the global namespace
Unknown
if such a context really actually exists.
Unknown
But it might also disappear over time, right?
Unknown
And basically because it's self-coherent
Unknown
over any level of scale, we don't even have to make
Unknown
that decision about whether anyone needs to have the rights
Unknown
over one website that everybody gets to go to.
Unknown
Like, if everyone's trying to go to that website
Unknown
using that same word and eventually
Unknown
that's where it's gonna get routed, you know?
Unknown
- Yeah, that's what comes up for me immediately
Unknown
is how does someone, what's the preventative measure
Unknown
from someone gaming it and let's say brute forcing
Unknown
that name and trying to create the weighted reputation?
Unknown
- Yeah.
Unknown
- And how do you keep that around?
Unknown
Do you have like a very, you know,
Unknown
my guess my mind would be, is there a verification
Unknown
in place where the other addresses need to verify that
Unknown
and then it gets locked in?
Unknown
Or can someone just basically brute force the network
Unknown
in discovery and try to give it weight, you know?
Unknown
- Yeah, well, these are good questions.
Unknown
I guess like I'd probably go back
Unknown
to this nearest neighbor's thing.
Unknown
Like you can brute force stuff,
Unknown
but brute forcing real actions with real people over time
Unknown
that connects to your fingerprint is hard
Unknown
unless you want to live a fake life
Unknown
for the purpose of securing godfree.com.
Unknown
- I mean, it's kind of like if you set it up right,
Unknown
it's like, you know, someone taking over the name
Unknown
of your tree planting group because they planted
Unknown
the most trees and they got the naming rights to do so.
Unknown
And it's like, fair enough, you planted all the tree.
Unknown
- Sure, great, you achieved our goal.
Unknown
Yeah.
Unknown
- But it is pretty cool since everything is connected
Unknown
and you have this fingerprint of what you
Unknown
and your behavior look like.
Unknown
Yeah, you can do like re-associable keys
Unknown
and all this kind of stuff just by living.
Unknown
And because it's-
Unknown
- That's your unique blueprint and your ID really, right?
Unknown
- Yeah, and like, you know, this all needs to be tested
Unknown
and like to what degree that's a good idea
Unknown
and whether it works and, you know, like maybe
Unknown
you don't need an exact match.
Unknown
You need a match that four of your closest peers
Unknown
can recognize and plus you need a human element
Unknown
on top of that.
Unknown
That's like, well, you know, I started behaving differently
Unknown
'cause I went camping for two years and I came back and,
Unknown
you know, like, of course, yada, yada, yada.
Unknown
But yeah, we have a substrate now
Unknown
which can provide us a lot of affordances.
Unknown
And the thing is we need to get this auditing chain going,
Unknown
Jeff, so that we can actually get some of our trusted
Unknown
and, you know, intellectually capable people
Unknown
who are able to grok this to really audit
Unknown
all of the aspects of the system
Unknown
on not just like a user experience level
Unknown
but also a theoretical level
Unknown
and also an implementation level.
Unknown
Like, does this make sense on all these levels?
Unknown
So, Jeff, I don't know if that has managed to
Unknown
get installed with N8n or something.
Unknown
- Oh, yeah.
Unknown
- Yeah. - Some kind of auditing agent
Unknown
that has all the ins and outs.
Unknown
- Yeah, did you ditch the Wexflow thing
Unknown
and just put in N8n instead or is it using both?
Unknown
- N8n has been in for weeks, if not months.
Unknown
- Yeah. - Having my own self-hosted
Unknown
N8n which it basically said Wexflow
Unknown
is completely like feature redundant so we don't need it.
Unknown
- Yeah, great, great.
Unknown
- Same thing with every bug tool I gave it.
Unknown
It was like your system's already better
Unknown
if you wanna spin up some of these features specifically
Unknown
you can but keep your own stack
Unknown
and just spin up the features you want.
Unknown
And I was like, nice.
Unknown
- Did you throw in Cricut?
Unknown
- Yeah, it said Cricut too.
Unknown
It just introduces dependencies we don't need.
Unknown
It's like, we could do all of that
Unknown
with what we have already built.
Unknown
- But the thing I liked about Cricut
Unknown
was that like people in their browser experience
Unknown
can just press like screen record
Unknown
and whatever and it catches the bugs
Unknown
but that's already in there.
Unknown
- We'll build it, it's being built.
Unknown
Like right now. - Oh, okay.
Unknown
Okay, cool.
Unknown
- Cool, so yeah.
Unknown
- Nice.
Unknown
- I should run for dinner.
Unknown
My folks called me a while ago
Unknown
but this is all I think about and talk about at the moment.
Unknown
Like I also like can't sleep
Unknown
and wake up early thinking about it.
Unknown
Like I sleep with my computer next to me now.
Unknown
(laughing)
Unknown
And I like wake up and I'm like, wait, what the fuck?
Unknown
Blah, blah, blah, blah.
Unknown
And it just starts going and every day I'm more blown away.
Unknown
So I don't know what happens with this
Unknown
but I think, yes, we keep it on the down low.
Unknown
It's being built as fast as we understand it.
Unknown
I know that's scary for some
Unknown
but I have had my hands on this for a long time
Unknown
and I see and I need to catch you up.
Unknown
We have a lot of what we need already built.
Unknown
The backlog system, the audit system,
Unknown
I just installed a key rotation system today.
Unknown
We have a lot already built.
Unknown
And I'm not saying let's put anything into production.
Unknown
I mean, other than like testing on our space.
Unknown
I'm not saying anybody should use shit.
Unknown
And yes, we definitely need more eyes and minds on this
Unknown
but I also wanna follow through with this.
Unknown
Like I wanna show, not tell.
Unknown
'Cause I think we need examples
Unknown
before people can grok what the hell this does.
Unknown
- Yeah, and I'm for that.
Unknown
Like basically it might be a point of tension
Unknown
that's not a bad thing.
Unknown
But I'm just, that's the word in social literacy or whatever.
Unknown
- Yes.
Unknown
- Yeah, like basically I think there's a strategic benefit
Unknown
in having like not evangelizing
Unknown
and telling everybody about this
Unknown
but just in people whose work and demonstrated sacrifice
Unknown
towards this stuff has earned them the right to be in the room.
Unknown
Because it's like, you know,
Unknown
once you start sharing shit with people,
Unknown
then they can share it with other people.
Unknown
But those people haven't actually gone
Unknown
through the internal change to have the philosophies
Unknown
that allow them to apply it to the good stuff.
Unknown
And then basically rich financiers of a certain persuasion
Unknown
end up with all of the bleeding edge
Unknown
of the bleeding edge stuff
Unknown
and apply it to hyper surveillance capitalism again
Unknown
or whatever the fuck.
Unknown
And like we don't want that.
Unknown
So yeah, I'm kind of trying to lobby Jeff to be like,
Unknown
like for me, a lot of this work comes out
Unknown
of a very spiritual place of like changing your own way
Unknown
of seeing and transcendence and really applied to like,
Unknown
how do we make the world a better place?
Unknown
So I feel quite personal about it.
Unknown
- Beautiful.
Unknown
And so even trusted people that maybe have a different paradigm
Unknown
or maybe just aren't here in this room for some reason.
Unknown
Well, they're not here in this room.
Unknown
And so they will get the stuff
Unknown
when it makes sense to get the stuff.
Unknown
But I think I would rather really,
Unknown
like we have trust organs as human beings.
Unknown
For some reason with God free,
Unknown
I can hear that Jeff has been talking with you a lot
Unknown
and using the ZK stuff.
Unknown
You have a clover on your profile picture
Unknown
and there's some connection with the Knights Templar
Unknown
and I vibe on that.
Unknown
So like for me, there's enough to kind of be like,
Unknown
that all maps for me.
Unknown
Whereas like another personality that I won't name,
Unknown
like Jeff, even if you trust them,
Unknown
for me, that's like, that's still evangelism.
Unknown
It's like, well, they're not here in this room
Unknown
because they are working on something else.
Unknown
And like, we can have that conversation.
Unknown
I'm down with that.
Unknown
But anyway, I'm just trying to express out there right now
Unknown
that like, let's keep it on the down low.
Unknown
Let's diffuse it organically.
Unknown
Let's have the minds that we need to have on it
Unknown
because we know the sub components in this room
Unknown
and get it to a certain point of integration
Unknown
before introducing a little wider of a circle
Unknown
and so on and so forth.
Unknown
And like, yeah, Roberto needs to be,
Unknown
yeah, because I, you know, I went on a tangent with Jeff
Unknown
like I've been in those rooms where, you know,
Unknown
for all these people working on high order stuff,
Unknown
you kind of know that not many people in the world
Unknown
get what you're talking about.
Unknown
And then you finally get in a room
Unknown
where you're with a bunch of people
Unknown
who can get what you're talking about.
Unknown
But I've been in that room,
Unknown
like in the BitNation conference where I met Roberto
Unknown
and you have a certain order of intelligence,
Unknown
but you have very different personality profiles
Unknown
and belief systems for what is right
Unknown
and good in the world, for example.
Unknown
And you kind of become aware that these are the people
Unknown
that will influence the future,
Unknown
but they might become my nemesis.
Unknown
If, for example, their model
Unknown
and their way of seeing the world gets out there.
Unknown
- Well said.
Unknown
- And it's always this weird thing.
Unknown
Like you finally find your people,
Unknown
but they're not your people.
Unknown
And you kind of know that one day when you leave
Unknown
that hackathon or conference or whatever,
Unknown
maybe in 10 years time,
Unknown
you're gonna be that aging IBM engineer
Unknown
with your long beard, smoking a doobie and being like,
Unknown
this is like, I met this guy in San Francisco once
Unknown
and he was like an 80 year old ex IBM engineer
Unknown
who was really mad about Trump being elected.
Unknown
And he was like, this isn't what we built the internet for.
Unknown
You know, like he was at this place,
Unknown
like building a tall ship and smoking like his joint
Unknown
at 80 years old and like complaining to the kids.
Unknown
Like, you know, I was in that room
Unknown
and a different decision got made
Unknown
to the one that I thought should have been made.
Unknown
And like, it's a story that has been told a thousand times.
Unknown
- I was just gonna say that.
Unknown
It's happened to me on a few occasions.
Unknown
- Yeah.
Unknown
Yeah, and so let's use our trust organs.
Unknown
Like, I know Jeff's excited.
Unknown
Like, you know, if you've ever watched the movie Shogun
Unknown
or like the series Shogun, you know,
Unknown
it's like in feudal Japan, one guy
Unknown
who was there from the beginning.
Unknown
How did he manage to be the guy left standing
Unknown
that brought Japan into the Tokugawa Shogunate?
Unknown
Even after these crazy people like Odenobunaga
Unknown
and like Toyotomi Hideyoshi and all these other generals
Unknown
went like rampaging and unifying Japan.
Unknown
It was the guy who kind of just kept out of trouble.
Unknown
Was modeling everything in a super smart way.
Unknown
Watching everyone else go down their weird parts
Unknown
that he knew would get into dead ends
Unknown
and then being the right person at the right time
Unknown
to pick it up at the moment of inflection.
Unknown
And we're seeing like the world collapse around us.
Unknown
We're seeing a bunch of stuff happen.
Unknown
And we know that there's a decline happening
Unknown
that we're gonna reach an inflection point
Unknown
where our rising star is gonna meet that.
Unknown
But we gotta be patient.
Unknown
We gotta wait for that point
Unknown
and we gotta be there to seize it
Unknown
rather than kind of projecting out
Unknown
like we're working on cool stuff, please join us.
Unknown
We're working on cool stuff.
Unknown
And then basically I'm gonna be very cautious
Unknown
with the AI recording things,
Unknown
but certain elite capitalist class
Unknown
co-opting everything because we need funding
Unknown
and then being able to reassert their dominance
Unknown
for the next generation in anthropological progress.
Unknown
Like I've spent 10 years staying up at night
Unknown
worrying about that and strategizing against it.
Unknown
I really hope at the very least that you can respect
Unknown
that there's a wisdom in my insistence
Unknown
on keeping this on the down low and--
Unknown
- 100%.
Unknown
- Yeah.
Unknown
- I feel like you're saying it
Unknown
like I have agreed with you all along
Unknown
because I have agreed with you all along, Brian.
Unknown
And I do think this is an important balance, counterbalance.
Unknown
I had this with Griff.
Unknown
I was the one that was advertising thinking about stuff.
Unknown
Griff was flying ahead.
Unknown
I am not aiming to do that.
Unknown
That is not my modality.
Unknown
I'm not going to push anything
Unknown
before anything needs to be pushed.
Unknown
I am very, very patient.
Unknown
We are years ahead.
Unknown
We are years ahead.
Unknown
This stuff can roll out when and as to who is necessary.
Unknown
I think it's actually critical that this stuff rolls out
Unknown
in, as you say, in the right way.
Unknown
And we can do a lot underground.
Unknown
We don't need to go anywhere with this.
Unknown
I don't need money.
Unknown
We've got all the money already coming in.
Unknown
Like I honestly think this whole like Janice thing
Unknown
we should do as like a totally anonymous account.
Unknown
Like I haven't told anyone more than who's in this room,
Unknown
Rory, and like I haven't even mentioned names to be by.
Unknown
I'm telling people that I'm doing stuff about addressing
Unknown
but like no specifics.
Unknown
Just like this is insane.
Unknown
We could get like anonymous publication
Unknown
with like your writing style with like, you know,
Unknown
collaborative, we could figure it out.
Unknown
We can like lay out all this stuff
Unknown
as a completely separate thing, you know,
Unknown
when, if and when it's ready, alongside, you know,
Unknown
the stuff that we're doing with CLF
Unknown
and all the other stuff.
Unknown
Like there's, we can just build it into the backend.
Unknown
And then like for me, it's just interesting to experiment
Unknown
with it, how it all fits together.
Unknown
Cause I think by the time we need it, it'll be ready.
Unknown
And like, of course, ready, ready for audit.
Unknown
Like I should say, not ready for production,
Unknown
ready for testing audit because it's all stitched together.
Unknown
And I think it's gonna like, once we get like Zen in there
Unknown
and Tom, Meshnet Tom, you Brian and Godfrey.
Unknown
And like, and I want, I want to replicate the stack
Unknown
like in Roberto, this, and this can host the stack,
Unknown
you know, this can be the stack.
Unknown
This can like, it can do so fucking much.
Unknown
- So yeah, the thing is at some level,
Unknown
we're going to have to help transfer the application
Unknown
development and membrane computing paradigm
Unknown
so that people get how to rebuild their applications
Unknown
in a way that takes advantage of membrane computing.
Unknown
But yeah.
Unknown
- I think there's a way with the small group though,
Unknown
to be able to test and iterate
Unknown
till you have a solid proof of concept
Unknown
and then lock some things down
Unknown
and then open up a public iteration of that, not public,
Unknown
but like an extended permission directory
Unknown
where people can utilize that,
Unknown
but they don't have access to everything.
Unknown
- Exactly.
Unknown
Yeah, like people don't need it.
Unknown
And it's to our strategic benefit
Unknown
while the baby is still in the nursery
Unknown
to like keep them cached and like obfuscate
Unknown
to some degree how it works.
Unknown
Like people don't need to know,
Unknown
they just need to be able to see like,
Unknown
oh, that's really cool.
Unknown
I can put my Trello cards in a higher level group.
Unknown
- Right, exactly.
Unknown
Now, your internal opsec is spot on
Unknown
and I absolutely love and I'm getting chills here
Unknown
when you speak about the policies and the protocols
Unknown
on how to go about this in a healthy holistic way
Unknown
because what I was getting from what you're sharing
Unknown
and Jeff and I talked about this,
Unknown
we've talked about it quite a few times,
Unknown
is the inner work that people do
Unknown
because there's a level of validation and self need
Unknown
that they have and it's wrapped around money.
Unknown
And there's an element of this
Unknown
where there's true people out there building
Unknown
for the greater cause of humanity's best benefit
Unknown
and then there's others doing it for themselves.
Unknown
And that's a huge difference of the quality
Unknown
and the work that the humans done on internally
Unknown
to even be able to understand that to begin with.
Unknown
So I'll leave that there.
Unknown
- Yeah, love that.
Unknown
It's really nice to hear that said
Unknown
and like we can all look at the web three space
Unknown
and see how quickly through sort of descent
Unknown
into evangelism and like look at me
Unknown
that the whole space has become terribly corrupted
Unknown
and it's feeding.
Unknown
I mean, it had also like fundamental paradigmatic flaws
Unknown
that enabled it to be co-opted
Unknown
but at the same time, people will find a way.
Unknown
And so yeah, one of Michelle's things,
Unknown
like he's gone and looked at meta history, right?
Unknown
And like how new things come into being,
Unknown
how you get civilizational transitions.
Unknown
And like, I hope Jeff can hear this,
Unknown
but basically it's always the warrior monks
Unknown
that shepherd in the transition.
Unknown
It's the Buddhist warrior monks.
Unknown
It's the Templars.
Unknown
- I can hear everything you say, Brian.
Unknown
- Yeah.
Unknown
- Oh my God, I love this.
Unknown
- And like I do think some of the people in this room
Unknown
are that way shaped, like I can sense it, right?
Unknown
And that is earned and that is forged
Unknown
through the formation of character.
Unknown
And yeah, I think just there's some wisdom
Unknown
and life experience that it sounds like
Unknown
you've had as well, Godfrey,
Unknown
where maybe you gave it away too quickly
Unknown
in your eagerness or desire to be seen.
Unknown
Or like, you know, it's a hard way
Unknown
when you've got all this inside you
Unknown
and nobody understands your brilliance or anything.
Unknown
You kind of want to get it all out there.
Unknown
And like, I've been out of the space for 10 years.
Unknown
I just can't even believe it.
Unknown
Like, you know, Roberto, we got on meetings
Unknown
for the first time in like six or seven years
Unknown
and we're introducing when we met each other
Unknown
and having to say it was a decade ago
Unknown
and how little has been done since is painful.
Unknown
But like, I see a divine reason in why,
Unknown
like I was the one tasked with the publication.
Unknown
And for some reason, like a deep internal reason,
Unknown
I couldn't get past the blockage
Unknown
or the observance of like not publishing
Unknown
because there was no capacity for us to implement.
Unknown
And like, I think I learned things in the intervening time
Unknown
about the structure of power in the world,
Unknown
who it is, how it operates,
Unknown
that I'm really glad I didn't actually go
Unknown
to some early hackathon with Andrus and Horowitz
Unknown
buying up all the rights to the ideas
Unknown
and like co-opting them.
Unknown
That's, so I was smart in some way.
Unknown
I was like, I'm not going to tell anyone the whole idea.
Unknown
I'm just going to break it down.
Unknown
It's some tiny chunk and be like,
Unknown
we're making an art project.
Unknown
Like, can you help me make a chain of artworks?
Unknown
- You got to talk about that publication pipeline
Unknown
you built today.
Unknown
What Brian is looking for,
Unknown
Godfrey just built like and we'll snap it in our space.
Unknown
It's going to be fun.
Unknown
- Oh, you mean, so are you talking
Unknown
about the decentralized hosting thing?
Unknown
Okay, yeah.
Unknown
So we, I love the concept of self-hosting everything.
Unknown
You are the server, you're the client, the whole deal.
Unknown
And so I basically had my client
Unknown
create a local web host that pins to IPFS, right?
Unknown
So you build all your websites locally
Unknown
and then it'll push it to IPFS
Unknown
and then make it publicly available.
Unknown
So your website's hosted on your own device
Unknown
available on IPFS and then you can forward
Unknown
or mask the domain to whatever you want.
Unknown
And then I was like, oh shit.
Unknown
So now we need to have web mesh somehow have a way
Unknown
to view those websites over reticulum.
Unknown
So I'm working on that now,
Unknown
but I got the IPFS hosting set up and working.
Unknown
- Right.
Unknown
So that includes hosting like sharding the content
Unknown
but also pinning it, right?
Unknown
- Yeah.
Unknown
- That's really cool.
Unknown
So question, like yeah, what I was asking Jeff for is like
Unknown
basically a system where like idea can go live
Unknown
instantly, but it's non-taked downable.
Unknown
And it's all self-hosted.
Unknown
But yeah, the non-taked downable part
Unknown
is where we have to throw in some of these
Unknown
like maybe handshake or something
Unknown
where like the naming system can be applied on top of this.
Unknown
But basically can I go on like Obsidian
Unknown
and X the other drawer and like write all my notes
Unknown
and have that locally in a folder
Unknown
and then use your system to like publish to web
Unknown
in a way where at least on the where the assets are stored
Unknown
and et cetera, it's all under my control
Unknown
and it's non-centralized.
Unknown
- Yeah, absolutely there should be.
Unknown
I mean, of course I need to dive in.
Unknown
But yeah, if it's on your local device
Unknown
unless someone has access to your device
Unknown
there's no way for them tamper with it.
Unknown
- That's super awesome.
Unknown
- Because it's pinned on IPFS, yeah.
Unknown
And we could set up permissions too.
Unknown
- Yeah, and then yeah, like the one bit then
Unknown
if we can think about how to do this
Unknown
without having to use the fractal namespace thing yet,
Unknown
like so one, the reason I got interested
Unknown
in handshake naming system is like, you know, ENS
Unknown
where you can have like a human readable name
Unknown
that applies to your Ethereum address.
Unknown
Yeah, but unfortunately that's all centralized
Unknown
and crappy anyway.
Unknown
Handshake naming system, basically a whole separate system
Unknown
for doing the auctions and stuff on names
Unknown
and they like massively opened up the namespace
Unknown
so that there's way more top level domains and stuff
Unknown
so that things aren't super expensive.
Unknown
But the problem with it is that what seems like a problem
Unknown
is that you have to point your browser to it as a DNS
Unknown
because it's not one of the officially sanctioned one
Unknown
that gets built into people's browsers.
Unknown
- Oh yeah, I see.
Unknown
- But what's cool about that is we don't care
Unknown
about 99% of people at this point.
Unknown
Like we can use a non-taked downable
Unknown
decentralized naming system.
Unknown
Like no government can go to ICANN
Unknown
and be like, block this domain.
Unknown
Like can we somehow add a non-taked downable,
Unknown
like this is a central, still centralized part of the stack,
Unknown
right?
Unknown
How do we kind of like Cy Hub?
Unknown
They have multiple different domains
Unknown
that I guess they just continually update their hosting table
Unknown
to like if some government takes down cyhub.com
Unknown
then it goes to cyhub.se
Unknown
and then if that gets taken down it goes to cyhub.kr.
Unknown
- Right.
Unknown
- Like can we add that,
Unknown
still using conventional systems to our sites?
Unknown
That would be cool.
Unknown
- Right.
Unknown
- Yeah, that would be.
Unknown
- Yeah, and maybe like Handshake is a cool way to do that.
Unknown
But then it also means that like well, you know what?
Unknown
Maybe using Handshake is the way to do that.
Unknown
You can still use an ICANN accredited domain
Unknown
for the one that most people use.
Unknown
And that's what keeps it live to the general internet.
Unknown
But in the fallback, you can also host it
Unknown
on all these other domains
Unknown
that are pointed to each other that are on Handshake.
Unknown
And people aren't gonna bother taking that down
Unknown
'cause it's not in browsers, but the people who matter
Unknown
can just put the DNS server in their browser.
Unknown
And there are always more on that level, yeah.
Unknown
- No, that makes sense.
Unknown
Then you have redundancy of different networks
Unknown
all able to be used simultaneously.
Unknown
I wonder if there's a way to make like a web browser extension
Unknown
that will give you that accessibility.
Unknown
- Absolutely, make it simple, right?
Unknown
Like install extension and then all it does
Unknown
is add like one config line to your browser.
Unknown
- Right.
Unknown
- Yeah, that'll be cool.
Unknown
I mean, then also it's like, yeah,
Unknown
like I haven't even gotten started on this, Jeff.
Unknown
Like what is the most user friendly way
Unknown
to implement all of this stuff we're talking about?
Unknown
Like do you actually need browser extensions
Unknown
if people were using this stuff or?
Unknown
- Right.
Unknown
- All you need is to do handshakes with other addresses
Unknown
and then you already got all the functionality
Unknown
just by web being on the substrate.
Unknown
Like, yeah.
Unknown
- Damn, incredible.
Unknown
Oh my God.
Unknown
- Yo, God for you there to pop on cam for a bit
Unknown
'cause I actually have been waiting for you two to meet
Unknown
for a long time.
Unknown
Totally agree with everything you said, Brian,
Unknown
and I'm happy to play the counterpart
Unknown
of that generative friction of speed ahead
Unknown
and slow down and integrate.
Unknown
Nothing is in a rush.
Unknown
- Who to tell it to.
Unknown
- That's a big one, yeah.
Unknown
- Absolutely, yeah, absolutely.
Unknown
As we've all spoken about, we know who our enemies are.
Unknown
We know they're all around.
Unknown
That's why we're on a self-hosted chat recording
Unknown
with a self-hosted bot running through
Unknown
our self-hosted infrastructure
Unknown
that's using our own self-hosted stuff for transcribing,
Unknown
for example.
Unknown
- But the other thing is gossip.
Unknown
Like, other people might not have been forged
Unknown
in the same way and might have looser protocols
Unknown
about like who to tell because it's cool and exciting
Unknown
and you start to lose control of that chain,
Unknown
which you're gonna have to accept at some point.
Unknown
- The other side of it is this unlocks things for human,
Unknown
this can't stay a secret.
Unknown
It can't stay a secret.
Unknown
- Of course not.
Unknown
- And it will spread through the appropriate virality
Unknown
just like the R space stuff, just like the ZK stuff.
Unknown
Like it's all underground until it fruits everywhere.
Unknown
I am so happy to be underground.
Unknown
I don't wanna be anywhere but underground.
Unknown
I need to get paid.
Unknown
This is like internet changing,
Unknown
possibly world changing innovation.
Unknown
Like it needs to be in the domain of humanity.
Unknown
It needs to like exist such that we can solve
Unknown
previously computationally intractable problems
Unknown
and turn them into like the appropriate like mycelial flow.
Unknown
This is like the data flow systems we're talking about.
Unknown
It's literally putting a cadence like the temporality.
Unknown
It's like conviction data, you know?
Unknown
It like propagates, it percolates through the network.
Unknown
- And of course that's the point of why it was made.
Unknown
- But yeah, so I'm just impressing again,
Unknown
my point of view on this that like it needs to flow
Unknown
but then the discernment and assessment
Unknown
of the forging of character of the person
Unknown
that you're flowing it to is essential
Unknown
because once you get to one person
Unknown
who has not been through that forging,
Unknown
well, oh, what a cool idea.
Unknown
I'll just share it with everyone
Unknown
because I don't understand the pain and the sacrifice
Unknown
or whatever it is and the internal mental changes
Unknown
that had to go on to do that.
Unknown
So like, you know, even, I'm just gonna say the name,
Unknown
like even a Zarrigum, so like I've never met him.
Unknown
And like, you know, at a certain point,
Unknown
I just have to defer to like Jeff's a good guy,
Unknown
he'll choose, right?
Unknown
And I can't control it, but at the same time,
Unknown
it's like, why is the person not in the room already?
Unknown
And that's like the level that I'm impressing
Unknown
of like selection criteria.
Unknown
It's like, you end up in the room
Unknown
because you end up in the room.
Unknown
And like, I have friends that I'm not gonna tell
Unknown
and they're smart and we've been working
Unknown
on similar stuff for ages, but it's like,
Unknown
if you keep the threshold high,
Unknown
then it will percolate at a slower rate
Unknown
with a high threshold, right?
Unknown
And like, there is no threshold, I hear you, I agree.
Unknown
And please trust me, I need your trust.
Unknown
Zarrigum is the highest threshold for this stuff possible.
Unknown
He is one of the only people outside of like Godfrey, Rory.
Unknown
And I think we stretched Rory's brain a bit today too.
Unknown
Like, I don't think that was comfortable for him.
Unknown
(Zarrigum laughs)
Unknown
There are very few people who can put together,
Unknown
as I said, I think the other, was it to you,
Unknown
that there are very few people that span
Unknown
all of the cross-section of these technologies
Unknown
to understand what the fuck we're even talking about
Unknown
or why that's even important.
Unknown
Most people don't care.
Unknown
I've talked to my parents, my brother and sister.
Unknown
All I've said is universal addressing.
Unknown
And I've talked about like the context
Unknown
of why that is relevant to normal everyday people.
Unknown
They're not gonna tell anybody.
Unknown
The only person who knows about it outside of this group
Unknown
is Rory.
Unknown
We need Rory's brain on this and Roberto.
Unknown
And we need Zarrigum's brain on this too, absolutely.
Unknown
He can test all of the formalisms.
Unknown
They can like, if and when needed,
Unknown
I'm not even saying throw stuff at him.
Unknown
I'm saying he will grok the ideas
Unknown
and he will have constructive feedback.
Unknown
- So at this point, I can say,
Unknown
I think I've impressed my point of view upon you.
Unknown
And I do trust you.
Unknown
I would feel more comfortable
Unknown
if I could meet the person first.
Unknown
I think I've like walked past him at a hackathon.
Unknown
But yeah, it's like, for me a lot--
Unknown
- I'll call you and I'm going to his house next week.
Unknown
- That would be great, yeah.
Unknown
So a lot comes down to vibes.
Unknown
Like I can assess the vibes of someone
Unknown
that I've had some interactions with, but I can't.
Unknown
So yeah, like I'm going to say,
Unknown
I've probably said my piece.
Unknown
And then maybe let's take it up as a mildly,
Unknown
like a loose protocol.
Unknown
When you're bringing someone in,
Unknown
introduce them to the group first.
Unknown
And you need to propagate the same level
Unknown
of carefulness to that.
Unknown
Like have this conversation in the same way to that person
Unknown
and help them understand why.
Unknown
Like what are the risks of overpropagating this thing
Unknown
before we've actually gotten it to a point?
Unknown
Like if we're 10 years ahead
Unknown
of even the leading research institutions, et cetera,
Unknown
on a lot of things, like we might, yeah.
Unknown
And like the ability for capital to--
Unknown
- We're looking here to be honest.
Unknown
I don't think 10 people you were talking about this with
Unknown
would understand.
Unknown
They just don't have the content.
Unknown
- Yeah.
Unknown
Maybe there's a way to set up a criteria sheet
Unknown
that's really locked down and then have a,
Unknown
like a feedback--
Unknown
- It's in the addressing.
Unknown
It's in the addressing.
Unknown
- Well, hold on, as they enter the group.
Unknown
- Well, hold on real quick.
Unknown
As they enter the group, they fill out a form
Unknown
and you basically get, they ask these questions.
Unknown
(laughs)
Unknown
- No forms, addressing and encryption.
Unknown
No forms, don't worry.
Unknown
I'll explain.
Unknown
No forms.
Unknown
(laughs)
Unknown
- But to the point of like a human protocol,
Unknown
like we have trust organs.
Unknown
We have a conversation with someone.
Unknown
We can pick up very quickly
Unknown
if we assess that they're a good person,
Unknown
if we can trust them, et cetera, et cetera.
Unknown
Like let's just,
Unknown
we're elevating the level of care on this
Unknown
to DEF CON, whatever,
Unknown
and as long as that has been understood
Unknown
by everyone in the room.
Unknown
And we, if we bring someone in--
Unknown
- We're a week past that, man.
Unknown
We're a week past that.
Unknown
- Yeah, yeah.
Unknown
And if we bring-- - We agree.
Unknown
- And if we bring someone in,
Unknown
I think what we have to do is actually bring them in.
Unknown
Let them meet all the other people in the room.
Unknown
Like let's have a shared stewardship over who it is.
Unknown
And then go through a ritual together of like,
Unknown
do we all understand the level of care?
Unknown
And like for me, that's satisfactory.
Unknown
Then I can trust you about bringing someone in
Unknown
'cause bringing someone in means actually bringing them in,
Unknown
having FaceTime with the group,
Unknown
and then there's a shared bond of stewardship in that.
Unknown
And so like, if you can be cool with that,
Unknown
I can trust you with Zargum and let's bring them in.
Unknown
- Have you met Darren and Sean as well?
Unknown
(coughs)
Unknown
- No. - You met--
Unknown
- Oh, no.
Unknown
- Oh, no, we chat with everyone, but Darren.
Unknown
That's right, Darren's on PST.
Unknown
- Yeah, so if you wanna bring them in,
Unknown
let's do it via an actual meet the group,
Unknown
bring them in.
Unknown
Does that make sense?
Unknown
But maybe it's like, you can drop some breadcrumbs,
Unknown
assess the person's interest.
Unknown
If they're like, wow, this is really cool,
Unknown
then be like, there's more, but you have to come in.
Unknown
Is that cool? - I have an idea.
Unknown
Yeah, not only--
Unknown
- Yeah, that sounds great.
Unknown
- Let's do it with hashed addressing.
Unknown
'Cause by the time we're ready, it's gonna be ready.
Unknown
- But I do like the group call
Unknown
and just to feel the energy and the frequency of the person
Unknown
that is coming in.
Unknown
- Yeah, because I've made mistakes as well, right?
Unknown
Like when I was in Chiang Mai,
Unknown
I, and like Michelle's made mistakes, right?
Unknown
Like, but he's on a different sphere.
Unknown
But like I sat down with a guy from New York.
Unknown
You know, he was smart.
Unknown
He could understand everything he was in.
Unknown
He wasn't actually at the same event I was,
Unknown
but he was showing up to the parties
Unknown
because he was in like a sister event.
Unknown
And we started hanging out lots.
Unknown
And one night I told him like the whole architecture of Theos.
Unknown
Thankfully, he probably wasn't smart enough
Unknown
to like photographic memory and write it all down,
Unknown
but he was smart enough to be like, this shit matters.
Unknown
But like his connections,
Unknown
I basically had a dream about him stabbing me
Unknown
in my apartment and the connections he has worry me.
Unknown
And there's a couple of instances like that
Unknown
that I think I've made mistakes,
Unknown
like giving away my passport information
Unknown
to somebody from Mossad
Unknown
in the guise of running this group called Bit Nation,
Unknown
this time with this guy.
Unknown
And like, I don't wanna make it, I regret those times
Unknown
and they sit heavy on my conscience.
Unknown
So like, let's do this in a careful way.
Unknown
And yeah, let's bring them in.
Unknown
Because like one wrong move to the perfectly wrong person
Unknown
seems to happen a lot in this space
Unknown
where the highly advanced people on the dark side
Unknown
are also looking.
Unknown
- I agree with you.
Unknown
I also think it doesn't really matter who sees this
Unknown
because our ultimate weapon is we're giving it away.
Unknown
Like this is like web internet level addressing shit
Unknown
and it needs to be global.
Unknown
Like the internet could not have been a company
Unknown
and neither can this.
Unknown
So anyone who tries to enclose this,
Unknown
and I mean, there are a million ways,
Unknown
including murdering us,
Unknown
that they could stop it from happening.
Unknown
So DEF CON umpteenth level of end dimension,
Unknown
hold on, accepted, received.
Unknown
I feel like we're getting to the point of like, yes.
Unknown
And- - Well, there is,
Unknown
there is an- - This is the security.
Unknown
Like the security is this thing as well.
Unknown
So all of this stuff, like I don't wanna, sorry.
Unknown
Yeah, go ahead.
Unknown
- No, I'm just gonna say,
Unknown
I think that there's a natural evolution of this
Unknown
and iteration as things start underground
Unknown
in open source in the private,
Unknown
there's iterations of the publics
Unknown
or that, you know, the more public facing side
Unknown
that can come out and things still stay locked down
Unknown
in the substrate, whereas not everything's exposed.
Unknown
But then as it grows,
Unknown
more gets brought out to the public,
Unknown
but like the core council stays with the doctrine,
Unknown
so to speak, or the protocol to where they can oversee it
Unknown
so it doesn't get corrupted.
Unknown
And, you know, we're dealing with that on a business level
Unknown
where, you know, we're creating this company,
Unknown
and I'll be quick on this,
Unknown
but we're creating a company,
Unknown
but we don't wanna exit on the protocol.
Unknown
We wanna exit on the verticals that come off of it.
Unknown
So that way, nobody can take the protocol
Unknown
and sell it to someone else,
Unknown
and then change that protocol.
Unknown
So it's just these layers of internal upset
Unknown
that allow the open source iterations to be accessible,
Unknown
but there's still a level of internal security.
Unknown
- So Jeff, understood. - This might be better.
Unknown
- Yeah, thanks, Godfrey.
Unknown
Yeah, I think it's also important for me to say,
Unknown
I understand you, Jeff, and that's the whole point,
Unknown
but then the point is then just like,
Unknown
just toe in that line perfectly
Unknown
where you're like surfing the edge
Unknown
of when you reach the inflection point
Unknown
of like public sharing of whatever level
Unknown
it makes sense to share at that time,
Unknown
but I do think from playing strategy games,
Unknown
from living life, from et cetera, from history,
Unknown
that like, you don't just go all out straightaway.
Unknown
You have to keep the baby in the nursery
Unknown
until it's nine years old or whatever,
Unknown
and can deal with a wild animal, right?
Unknown
- Maybe it is nine years old.
Unknown
- It's not good.
Unknown
(laughing)
Unknown
- You're so right. - Maybe, I love it.
Unknown
- Maybe this is the best.
Unknown
Maybe.
Unknown
- And you make sure.
Unknown
And like, you have the capacity
Unknown
to influence history right now, and like, that's important.
Unknown
So, choose very wisely whom you trust.
Unknown
- Are you from the future?
Unknown
This is crazy.
Unknown
(laughing)
Unknown
- Well, yeah, hey Jeff, when people of influence
Unknown
are looking to build something
Unknown
and they use GPT to find out who can help
Unknown
and that fucking directs them to you,
Unknown
I'd say, you know, it's important to consider
Unknown
what he's saying.
Unknown
- Anyway, I think we, things have been impressed.
Unknown
We'll all go away and we'll all listen to each other
Unknown
and trust each other to some degree.
Unknown
(laughing)
Unknown
But like, it's good.
Unknown
- Brian, let's go from the future to tell us,
Unknown
don't be risky with this.
Unknown
(laughing)
Unknown
- That's right, that's right.
Unknown
- Well, it's perfect.
Unknown
It speaks to me, yes it is.
Unknown
And it speaks to me in a healthy way to just, you know,
Unknown
that way the core, the source,
Unknown
well, is no way able to be corrupted.
Unknown
And I think that's very, very important,
Unknown
especially with one, you know,
Unknown
the way people are internally
Unknown
and the way people are externally usually is different.
Unknown
And that to me is why the world is in the situation it is,
Unknown
is there's a level of authentic accountability
Unknown
and honesty that people don't have with themself
Unknown
and then they pretend to be that on the outside.
Unknown
And that creates corruption at the core.
Unknown
And it creates a level of vulnerability
Unknown
by trusting something that's not verifiable.
Unknown
Anyways, enough of the said,
Unknown
I appreciate this mindset and I think it's very healthy.
Unknown
So.
Unknown
- Yeah, let's all go and reflect and come back on this.
Unknown
And like one thing I have to say, Jeff is like,
Unknown
you can tell that like I'm wearing my heart on my sleeve
Unknown
and my gut feels very sensitively and vulnerably
Unknown
about this stuff.
Unknown
I've made my whole life about it, right?
Unknown
But like, so I can already tell you,
Unknown
I start to have worries about sharing more with you
Unknown
if I feel worried about that trust extension
Unknown
through you to whom you trust
Unknown
and also that not going in the way that feels safe for me.
Unknown
So I'm just putting that out there.
Unknown
So you understand me, you don't have to do anything
Unknown
that I desire, but then I have to make choices
Unknown
then about where to allocate my trust.
Unknown
And, you know, and that's okay.
Unknown
Then that is organic, you know,
Unknown
if we have different ideas that is organic.
Unknown
There's a reason that we're in this room together.
Unknown
- What we need is communication.
Unknown
- Yeah, exactly. - And iteration.
Unknown
So we've identified the playing space.
Unknown
Now it's like just a feedback thing.
Unknown
Because we may and will and should disagree.
Unknown
And that's good.
Unknown
And now we have protocols for managing that.
Unknown
Like that's gonna be in the fucking addressing.
Unknown
- Yeah.
Unknown
And anyway, so I appreciate this conversation
Unknown
and thank you for sharing your perspective
Unknown
and yours Godfrey and Willow.
Unknown
We're making something pretty amazing.
Unknown
And yeah, I guess.
Unknown
- What an honor.
Unknown
What an honor to be here.
Unknown
- Yeah.
Unknown
- I wanted to do you a treat for a while.
Unknown
Godfrey, are you able to pop your face on cam for a bit
Unknown
or is your camera broken?
Unknown
Again, your laptop.
Unknown
- Oh yeah, yeah.
Unknown
I didn't do my hair.
Unknown
But sure, let's do this.
Unknown
- I woke up at five AM and then it was just squinting.
Unknown
- Oh, hey, nice to meet you Godfrey.
Unknown
- Yeah.
Unknown
- Great to meet you too.
Unknown
- So we're probably gonna meet, I guess, yeah.
Unknown
- Yeah.
Unknown
- Austria or Austria.
Unknown
Commons, what are we saying?
Unknown
Valley of the Commons.
Unknown
- Yeah.
Unknown
- Yes, they're gathering, CCG.
Unknown
- Yeah, and I--
Unknown
- And unfortunately, I won't...
Unknown
Yes.
Unknown
I won't make the Valley of the Commons
Unknown
'cause my son has his wedding on the 28th.
Unknown
Yeah, so.
Unknown
- So CCG.
Unknown
- Yep, physical.
Unknown
Hugs, let's go.
Unknown
- Yeah, sweet.
Unknown
And I'd love to hear more about everything you're working
Unknown
on Godfrey, like it's been a bit of a one way this call,
Unknown
but, you know, Jeff's obviously full into it
Unknown
and I don't actually know what you're working on.
Unknown
- Oh, shit.
Unknown
Oh, man.
Unknown
Damn.
Unknown
That was the last, like...
Unknown
- Real quick, strong metadata privacy,
Unknown
zero knowledge applications and edge hardware
Unknown
for local private AI.
Unknown
One of our big things that we're working on right now
Unknown
is locking in the mixed network
Unknown
so it decentralizes and then it unlocks
Unknown
metadata private zero knowledge applications.
Unknown
So that way developers can build applications
Unknown
with metadata privacy baked in.
Unknown
And then people can run the nodes and be incentivized
Unknown
for sharing compute, storage, bandwidth,
Unknown
and other utility that will grow on the system.
Unknown
And then the edge compute hardware
Unknown
will extend this all the way to the end user
Unknown
to where they have a tamper resistant hardware wallet,
Unknown
a local mixed node running, a local app stack
Unknown
so everything's self-hosted that they can build
Unknown
and run apps from locally.
Unknown
And then use that device to connect your other apps
Unknown
or your other devices too.
Unknown
So it's like what we call a fog compute device
Unknown
instead of a cloud.
Unknown
It's a local self-hosted cloud.
Unknown
And then your phone is like a missed terminal browser
Unknown
to access your fog compute.
Unknown
And one of the key things for us as local private AI
Unknown
is one of the core use cases.
Unknown
And being able to, so there's a paper
Unknown
that I can share with you
Unknown
where a fellow that works on a project called Prometheus
Unknown
who was funded by Jeff Bezos,
Unknown
he took our echo mix network protocol
Unknown
and built the first strong anonymous AI neural inference layer
Unknown
to where it does not allow,
Unknown
it's sender and receiver unlinkability.
Unknown
So there's no way for the system or the network
Unknown
to track who's prompting it or who's receiving messages.
Unknown
So it is a game changer on that.
Unknown
And then we have another protocol
Unknown
which is a metadata private group chat protocol
Unknown
that you'll be able to use
Unknown
which will unlink all that at the device network layer.
Unknown
So that way your device can't be surveilled,
Unknown
you can't get tracked, your IP, your location,
Unknown
your who, what, where, when, all of that.
Unknown
So that's a general run through.
Unknown
There's a ton more that we can share as we grow here
Unknown
but that's kind of a overview.
Unknown
- Sounds amazing.
Unknown
And I want you, your homework is to make Jeff
Unknown
get his prompts private.
Unknown
(laughs)
Unknown
- There we go, we talked about that.
Unknown
- How could we build sovereign?
Unknown
- How many weeks?
Unknown
- Private technology, if all our stuff's going through
Unknown
centralized AI.
Unknown
- All I need is a spec Godfrey, all I need is a spec.
Unknown
Send me what you got.
Unknown
- You got it Ralph.
Unknown
- Like for whatever's sake, get Jeff's prompts private
Unknown
and like I need to get off Gmail with my name dot com.
Unknown
Like (laughs)
Unknown
- Yes, no worry, we are still early enough
Unknown
and we're small enough
Unknown
that we have not tripped any alarms
Unknown
and we are ready to blast off into our own ZK encrypted
Unknown
context-aware data ecosystems.
Unknown
So this is the last vestige
Unknown
and we're still only like four people
Unknown
who are even aware of the consequences of this.
Unknown
- Yeah.
Unknown
- So to everyone else, this is very boring tech shit.
Unknown
- Yeah, can I say as an example, maybe as an exemplar,
Unknown
like to me, Roberto of all people is probably the one
Unknown
that should be here because he made alarms and, but
Unknown
- 100%
Unknown
- Let's follow our protocol and bring him in
Unknown
and test it and be like, hi everyone.
Unknown
This is Roberto, does it feel good?
Unknown
He hasn't had this level of a walkthrough.
Unknown
So, you know, if Godfrey is down with that,
Unknown
we can try to have a call where we formalize that.
Unknown
- Absolutely.
Unknown
- Yeah.
Unknown
Cool. Well, Jeff, we've got some,
Unknown
we've got some what's new to catch up on.
Unknown
- We do.
Unknown
Let's catch up when you wake up.
Unknown
Oh, no, you're waking up now.
Unknown
Let's catch up.
Unknown
- Yeah, it's like another 30 minutes of rest.
Unknown
This was probably the most intense morning.
Unknown
- Five AM.
Unknown
- Good morning, Brad.
Unknown
- Yeah, and my brother just got here last night.
Unknown
So maybe, yeah, maybe I'll take a,
Unknown
like when, when's good for you to call
Unknown
because it's also getting late for you, right?
Unknown
- No, it's only 6.30.
Unknown
Oh, I got the call in half an hour.
Unknown
So I'm gonna, I'm gonna go eat
Unknown
and then I have a call in half an hour till eight.
Unknown
But I mean, if you want to call me in after.
Unknown
- Okay. How about this?
Unknown
I just remembered we've got a Cosmo local call
Unknown
- Oh shit, yeah.
Unknown
So at 10, so we'll catch up at 10
Unknown
and then at three in the morning.
Unknown
- Is it, is it valuable?
Unknown
- Yeah, sorry about that.
Unknown
Is it valuable for us to catch up before 10?
Unknown
- Why don't we just do gentle?
Unknown
I don't think Michelle's gonna come
Unknown
because he's on conference.
Unknown
So we can just chat and get him into time.
Unknown
- Yeah.
Unknown
- And then I'll go to sleep and wake up at three.
Unknown
- Okay, so let's meet at our call time.
Unknown
And then that gives me some time to chill with my bro
Unknown
and you to get a rest.
Unknown
- Perfect.
Unknown
- Yeah, thanks so much for convening
Unknown
and also for your grace on my exertion of willpower.
Unknown
- Thank you for being brilliant
Unknown
and for exerting that willpower
Unknown
in the way that it needs to be exerted.
Unknown
And I hope that you know that you can trust me.
Unknown
And like this is why I'm happy to bring Godfrey into this
Unknown
because Godfrey and I have been building up this like
Unknown
this trust layer that I know I have with you.
Unknown
Like we met 10 years ago, we hung out.
Unknown
I've missed you ever since.
Unknown
I know you've been doing your own thing.
Unknown
I've been doing my own thing.
Unknown
But these ideas are not new.
Unknown
This thing is 10 years old.
Unknown
Like this is the culmination of the relationships
Unknown
and so on.
Unknown
And I already feel just based on the things
Unknown
we've talked about.
Unknown
And Brian, I will tell you full alignment with Godfrey
Unknown
in terms of like the things that we are aware of
Unknown
and working towards.
Unknown
And also I want to encourage speaking up,
Unknown
like having like feedback, like clear feedback,
Unknown
because I think we can clearly and easily honestly
Unknown
manage these kinds of tensions without the breakdowns
Unknown
that I've experienced, for example, with GRIF
Unknown
where it's just like toxic positivity
Unknown
and like you're trying to be so friendly
Unknown
that you can't disagree.
Unknown
But then you're like pushing stuff through like
Unknown
dowification of like, oh, well, the group just decided that.
Unknown
It's like, no, GRIF, like, are you not seeing this?
Unknown
So anyway, I think mature masculine warrior monks
Unknown
and mature feminine too, of course.
Unknown
But, you know, people who have done the work,
Unknown
this is absolutely a key, key aspect.
Unknown
And I feel like all of us and Rory as well,
Unknown
I know he comes in as quite the jester sometimes,
Unknown
but I think he just has the biggest fool card of us all.
Unknown
Hello.
Unknown
(laughing)
Unknown
Warrior monkeys, maybe, I don't know.
Unknown
(laughing)
Unknown
I like that.
Unknown
I do like the monkey 'cause it's like, you know, yeah.
Unknown
And I mean, GRIF is clever too.
Unknown
This is why he pushes all his stuff through Giveth.
Unknown
He's like, nobody's gonna come after the crypto charity.
Unknown
Like, and that's like, he's been innovating
Unknown
under the guise of the crypto charity for a long time.
Unknown
- But I can tell you that the GRIF,
Unknown
GRIF gave the big fat N.O. to me and Roberto 10 years ago.
Unknown
- GRIF continually says no to me.
Unknown
He said no to me last week.
Unknown
He said no to Godfreak.
Unknown
I'm just like, dude, he doesn't see it.
Unknown
There's something missing in his view.
Unknown
- But that's what I'm saying.
Unknown
Like, he's self-selected out of the group and that's fine.
Unknown
- Exactly, exactly, exactly.
Unknown
Right, right.
Unknown
He'll come in at the layer when he's needing to.
Unknown
- But he needs to come in.
Unknown
- Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Unknown
Yeah.
Unknown
- And I do trust you, Jeff.
Unknown
Like, yeah, it's true.
Unknown
Like, you know, even after 10 years,
Unknown
we're slipping back into a mode of working
Unknown
that clearly has an ease to it.
Unknown
So.
Unknown
- And massive leverage, dude.
Unknown
- Massive leverage. - Incredible.
Unknown
- And I appreciate being held to account too,
Unknown
because I know I'm very excited about the new
Unknown
and finishing the things from before.
Unknown
So I know there's a tension there within myself with that
Unknown
and having like accountability buddies.
Unknown
Honestly, I wanna help you publish, man.
Unknown
You and under the guise and auspice that makes sense.
Unknown
We need to build the publication pipeline first.
Unknown
But then I think we could do fucking anonymous,
Unknown
truly fucking anonymous posting about this shit
Unknown
where we can get all your ideas out there and mine.
Unknown
You know, like there's so much we need to fucking,
Unknown
and Godfrey's, and like all of these people.
Unknown
Like it's fucking insane.
Unknown
- Yeah, the tension is a good sign
Unknown
that we've got complimentary personality profiles.
Unknown
So we're going to be pushing and pulling
Unknown
on parts of each other,
Unknown
but we need like a group level awareness
Unknown
that this is all for our group benefit.
Unknown
- Right.
Unknown
(laughing)
Unknown
- Absolutely. - You make me uncomfortable
Unknown
with your speed of iteration and stuff,
Unknown
and I'm like, thank goodness.
Unknown
(laughing)
Unknown
- Yeah.
Unknown
- But you're too excited.
Unknown
So calm the fuck down.
Unknown
(laughing)
Unknown
- That's not so much weed.
Unknown
(laughing)
Unknown
- Oh, it's perfect.
Unknown
(laughing)
Unknown
- It's like, go slower, brain, go slower.
Unknown
(laughing)
Unknown
- It's like, I'm still coming up with this.
Unknown
Why are you making it real so quick?
Unknown
(laughing)
Unknown
- Oh, oh, and you added like,
Unknown
you added end dimensions to it.
Unknown
Oh, no, I have to like patch up.
Unknown
(laughing)
Unknown
- Yeah, spit out those docs, Jeff.
Unknown
Always have these docs spitting out
Unknown
and iterating that living archive, you know?
Unknown
- I need to tie you guys in.
Unknown
Actually, maybe I shouldn't tie you directly
Unknown
into my backlog, because Brian, you might cry.
Unknown
(laughing)
Unknown
I remember things going on in there.
Unknown
(laughing)
Unknown
It's like, why?
Unknown
Why?
Unknown
(laughing)
Unknown
It's gonna look good.
Unknown
(laughing)
Unknown
- Yeah, I mean, you know, for me,
Unknown
actually, yeah, we're overdue probably
Unknown
for a slowdown integration phase and an audit phase,
Unknown
and also just to push out like something.
Unknown
So like, little Holonate task manager
Unknown
or being able to access one website
Unknown
over the self-aware interface.
Unknown
And then we can give that to like ourselves as a group
Unknown
and play with it while then stepping onto the next phase
Unknown
of like implementing more stuff.
Unknown
- Yeah, I would say it would seem
Unknown
to have a very, very simple like core,
Unknown
and then everything's modularized
Unknown
to where you can have it all there,
Unknown
but you can turn on and off the modules.
Unknown
That way, you don't have to go through
Unknown
all the code to fix something, you know?
Unknown
Everything's in libraries and modules or something.
Unknown
- Yeah, can you say, like, link that back
Unknown
to a concrete example now?
Unknown
- Like, let's say you have the core protocol
Unknown
underneath everything.
Unknown
And I know you guys have been iterating
Unknown
and adding all this to it.
Unknown
Is there a way to strip away everything
Unknown
to have the core protocol,
Unknown
and then everything is a module built onto it?
Unknown
That way, you can easily target and find bugs
Unknown
in each of the parts of the stack that are being added.
Unknown
- Jeff knows the most about how it's all going together
Unknown
in his code soup over there.
Unknown
- Does that make sense, Jeff?
Unknown
- Yep.
Unknown
Code soup. - It's like a kernel in Linux.
Unknown
You know, you have your core kernel
Unknown
and then everything's modularized.
Unknown
- What do you call it?
Unknown
- Well, that's, I don't know
Unknown
what you guys are calling this core protocol.
Unknown
- It's got a name right now, which is just a joke.
Unknown
And it's a cool joke.
Unknown
It's Janice.
Unknown
- I love it.
Unknown
- Because Jeff randomly thought that he heard me say,
Unknown
Janice, when I actually said nothing.
Unknown
- And then we looked up what it was,
Unknown
and it was like a fucking boss.
Unknown
- Well, yeah, yeah, Janice is the Roman god
Unknown
that looks into the future in the past
Unknown
and stands on the threshold and, you know,
Unknown
the god of father time kind of figure.
Unknown
So we were like, that's good enough.
Unknown
Let's call it Janice.
Unknown
- Janice.
Unknown
(laughs)
Unknown
- And then starting to look into it is like,
Unknown
yo, this is actually like the god of thresholds
Unknown
and portals.
Unknown
So I was telling God for you, I don't know,
Unknown
maybe we were on signal before we were all chatting
Unknown
that I feel like this addressing thing turns like,
Unknown
okay, each of these innovations,
Unknown
whether it's like reticulum routing
Unknown
or zero knowledge metadata, private encryption
Unknown
or, you know,
Unknown
- Holonic address.
Unknown
- Holonic addressing, like the ephemeral,
Unknown
like each of these are fucking zords, you know?
Unknown
Like power agents, these zords are like fucking crazy
Unknown
ass technologies and this addressing system
Unknown
is like the spirit, the ephemeral backbone
Unknown
that like all of these zords now click into
Unknown
without even having to move from where they are.
Unknown
You know, they're now connected, you know?
Unknown
It's like we have this addressing that pulls together,
Unknown
this insane, it's a substrate, yeah.
Unknown
Yeah, so whoa.
Unknown
- Cool.
Unknown
- We need to think about it.
Unknown
I need to go eat, I'm starving.
Unknown
We're chatting in a few hours, Brian.
Unknown
I guess we're chatting in, sorry, God for you.
Unknown
I guess we're chatting in 15 minutes.
Unknown
I gotta go eat and give my brain a small rest.
Unknown
- Yeah, much appreciate meeting with both of you folks
Unknown
and Rory and looking forward to this.
Unknown
It's gonna build its own corpus and momentum, I think,
Unknown
because it's just too big to not,
Unknown
so we'll meet again soon.
Unknown
- I look forward, it was an absolute pleasure
Unknown
to connect with you.
Unknown
- Yeah, and lovely to meet you and see your face
Unknown
and thanks for your energy, it's a good one.
Unknown
- Ha ha, same, brother.
Unknown
- I'm also happy to throw names for a pre-vet list, you know,
Unknown
too, like I think Zargum needs to be here,
Unknown
I think Orion needs to be here.
Unknown
And I'm not saying even here, like all the time,
Unknown
they would have meaningful input and the right connections
Unknown
to take us to whatever stage we need to go to
Unknown
when we're ready for it.
Unknown
- Yeah, thanks, Jeff.
Unknown
And I appreciate your great communication about this.
Unknown
I feel like we've all earned some wisdom
Unknown
and better ways of engaging with this kind of stuff,
Unknown
so let's be fully on.
Unknown
(laughs)
Unknown
- Yes.
Unknown
- Lock in, Brian.
Unknown
- Lock in, boys.
Unknown
- Yes, I veed the Super Mario pill.
Unknown
Let's go.
Unknown
(laughs)
Unknown
- All right, catch you guys in a few.
Unknown
- Yeah, peace.
Unknown
- All right, blessings.
Unknown
- Yeah, thanks, guys.
Unknown
- Ciao.
Unknown
- Ciao.